It’s time to change of count of American war dead upward.
The Associated
Press has got hold of a preliminary government study on suicides by Iraq
and Afghanistan
war veterans. According to the VA, at least 283 combat veterans who left the
military between the start of the war in Afghanistan
on October 7, 2001 and the
end of 2005 took their own lives. In addition, 147 troops have killed
themselves in Iraq
and Afghanistan
since the wars began bringing the government count to 430.
The VA’s count is not a complete one, however. It does not
include members of the military who returned from Iraq
and then killed themselves before being discharged from the service – people like
Sgt Brian
Rand who shot himself in the head after returning home from his second
tour.
It also doesn’t include the deaths
of people like Sgt. James Dean who was shot by Maryland
state troopers after he barricaded himself in his father’s farmhouse. Observers
call those deaths “suicide by cop.”
And it doesn’t include the deaths of people like Sgt.
Gerald Cassidy, a 32 year old Indiana National Guardsman, who died at Fort Knox
five months after returning from Iraq
with brain damage from a roadside bomb.
How many more American deaths continue to go uncounted?
Regardless, it’s clear is that we need to change our count
of casualties upward from 4,229 US military deaths (3,842 in Iraq and 387 in
Afghanistan) to closer to 5,000 – possibly more when you consider those deaths
that still haven’t been counted.
The True Cost of war is often "excessively conservative"
Washington Post- Tuesday, March 18, 2008; 3:00 PM
Joseph E. Stiglitz, author and economist, was online Tuesday, March 18, at 3 p.m. ET to discuss his book, "The Three Trillion Dollar War," which was reviewed in Book World. The book is co-authored with Harvard University's Linda J. Bilmes.
This was my question for him:
Jacksonville, Fla.: "My husband is a 24-year-old combat veteran of OIF and OEF who testified in Winter Soldier near Washington, D.C., this past weekend to the failings of the Veteran's Healthcare Administration. How would the fact that 10,000 veterans have committed suicide upon returning home to the U.S. affect your calculation of the cost of the war? How much value should be assigned to each human life lost? The military gives us $500,000 if our loved ones die in battle, and nothing if they come home dead inside. To me, my husband's life is more valuable than then entire war debt, and no one could ever compensate me for what we both lost. Thank you."
Joseph E. Stiglitz: "You have emphasized one of the tragic costs of this war to which we did not give adequate attention. We noted the psychological problems facing many of the returning veterans--of the 700,000 returning veterans, more than a 100,000 have been diagnosed with problems, but the numbers are likely to get worse, as those with multiple deployments return. We should have valued the loss of life as a result of these suicides, using the same procedures we used for the loss of those who died in combat.
This is another example showing that our numbers were excessively conservative."
I am grateful for this answer, considering it is the first time I have heard anyone admit that active duty combat deaths and veterans suicide deaths should be valued using the same procedures. Only when we begin to change the way we assess value to human life when calculating statistics will the United States Congress be required to act on this information. Then, in the future, they can remember how expensive the price of aggression really is. So that our children will not forget the price of Iraq and Afghanistan like our generation forgot the price of Vietnam. This is a sad, sad reality, but there you have it. So, I would like to say to all researchers of veteran's issues and the costs of war: Open your ears and your hearts and listen to what the veterans have said at Winter Soldier and what they are still saying. What is more significant to a researched solution than first-person accounts?